Light Dreaming PTY LTD application to use the Mt Coot-tha public Gardens for a commercial Night Walks permanent light and sound show has been approved by BCC
APRIL 2024 UPDATE
Concerns are being raised about the Lumina proposal to light up sections of the Mt Coot-tha Botanic Gardens. The community submission period has closed and the application has been approved. You can still voice your concerns. Send a letter to the Lord Mayor!
Sign up for our newsletter, Coot-tha Conversations, to receive updates on development applications and other issues related to Mt Coot-tha.
The e-petition demanding the BCC rejects the Development Application for Lumina Night Walk at Brisbane Botanical Gardens at Mt Coot-tha gained over 600 signatures.
Artificial Light At Night (ALAN)
One of the submissions opposing the development application contained some very important information about microbats and the consequences of this proposed development. The consequences of which many of us are probably not aware.
"...the effect of Artificial Light At Night (ALAN) on already vulnerable microbat populations. Microbats have long been identified as key providers of ecosystem services, primarily due to their diet and foraging behaviour. They consume pathogen-carrying arthropods such as malariabearing mosquitos, pollinate and disperse seeds of culturally and economically important plant species, and suppress agricultural pest insects. Microbats provide enormous benefits to the economy and their role in the ecosystem is invaluable, yet they are often disregarded in development and planning initiatives. ALAN has only recently been discussed as a threat to biodiversity and the current literature suggests it has more negative than positive impacts on microbats. ALAN often attracts large numbers of insects that faster flying space-adapted species tend to exploit, though they are not always able to evade aerial predators that also use artificially lit areas as hunting grounds. Conversely, slower flying clutter-adapted species are more sensitive to artificially lit areas, indicating that responses are species-specific and conserving dark patches in urban areas is crucial for the persistence of microbat diversity. ALAN also disrupts microbat drinking behaviours and delays affected species’ emergence times from roosts, thus decreasing their foraging time and putting their health at risk".
You can help!
Take Action!
Print out some flyers and distribute them in your neighbourhood.
Presentation at The Hut Environmental and Community Association monthly meeting - Wednesday 26 October 2022 by Paul Campbell
(This article first appeared in the February issue of the THECA newsletter and excerpts are reproduced here with THECA’s permission.)
(Photograph taken from above the proposed site looking towards the city)
Paul described the location and planned display at the Botanic Gardens, pointing out that it lies in an area between the Western Freeway and the quarry that is currently very dark at night, and offers a refuge for nocturnal animals that require dark conditions.
The black area in the foreground includes the proposed site of the Lumina project in the Botanic Gardens.
The image shows that relative to human vision, many organisms have much greater sensitivity to shorter wavelengths of light, concentrated towards the ‘blue’ end of the visible spectrum and into the ultraviolet (UVA) range.
Unfortunately for such species, LED lights have a strong peak in exactly this blue end of the spectrum, meaning that they may be especially susceptible to disturbance by LEDs while humans are much less aware of light at those wavelengths.
What is at stake? What does the proposal entail?
Privatisation of at least 50 hectares of public land including Anzac Park, Toowong
Concept only Development Application
Not an Environmental Facility
Does not conform to the Mt Coot-tha Botanic Gardens Master Plan
Contrary to the purpose of a Botanic Garden
Undesirable impacts of light on nocturnal wildlife and plant groups
Noise from the shows, patrons and traffic until 11pm each night of operation
Traffic and parking negative impacts on the local area with up to 2,400 visitors each night
Theft of rare plants
Increased roadkill of native animals with increased traffic
Does not represent value for money and contribute to 'Brisbane Vision 2023'
Roma Street Parklands or City Botanic Gardens more appropriate locations
Ecology issues have not been addressed by the proponent. The impacts of light on microbats, owls and other nocturnal species could be significant. The proponent has not conducted any field surveys. The proponent acknowledged that the ecology report was from a “desk survey”.
The Lumina Night Walks proposal covers 8 sections of The Gardens, not just the Exotic Rainforest section as stated by Cr Krista Adams. The proposed "use area" is 4,512 m2 connected by a 1km long walking trail.
We do not want to see a re-run of the failed Zipline project that engaged in "tick the boxes" consultation and ended up costing Brisbane ratepayers dearly.
There is no detail on how the proponent concludes “minimal impacts on wildlife or surrounding residents”.
National Light Pollution Guidelines for Wildlife
Animals and humans perceive light differently. Commercial light monitoring instruments currently focus on measuring the region of the spectrum most visible to humans. It is important to recognise and account for this fact when monitoring light for wildlife impact assessment purposes. Commercial light modelling programs also focus on light most visible to humans and this should also be recognised and accounted for in the impact assessment of artificial light on wildlife.
The aim of the Guidelines is that artificial light will be managed so wildlife is:
1. Not disrupted within, nor displaced from, important habitat; and
2. Able to undertake critical behaviours such as foraging, reproduction and dispersal.
Many residents who turned up for the "Information Sharing Evening" were bitterly disappointed that BCC councillor and Gardens Curator failed to show up and be answerable to community concerns.